Sama Hoole X-berichten

Erling Haaland eats cow hearts, liver and raw milk, and this summer the founder of America's loudest vegan doctors' group called it dirty fuel.

Standing first. Haaland is the most feared finisher in world football, a man who spent this summer leading Norway at their first World Cup finals since 1998, running on around 6,000 calories a day. He talks about the diet the way a farmer talks about feed: eating quality food that is as local as possible, he says, is the most important thing.

On his plate:

- Beef heart
- Liver
- Raw milk
- Beef

On the worry list of Neal Barnard, president of the Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine:

- Saturated fat
- Cholesterol
- The arteries nobody can see

Barnard's case, made on his own organisation's podcast, runs like a car advert in reverse. An athlete burns fuel hard, the fuel has impurities, and a hard-driven engine with dirty fuel gets damaged. You can look extremely healthy on the outside, he said, and nobody can see how the arteries are doing.

That last line is the whole case. It is a guess about something hidden, offered against a body the entire planet watches for 90 minutes at a time.

Every piece of the dirty fuel is the stuff a human body is physically built from. The heart is the densest muscle food on an animal, the liver is its vitamin store, and the milk is what mammals feed their young when growth is the only job going. Haaland eats the parts of the animal his great-grandparents in rural Norway would have recognised, and his body does precisely what a body fed like that is meant to do.

The clean fuel theory has to speculate about arteries it has never seen. The dirty fuel is on the pitch every weekend, and you can watch it score.



Mike
 
I started carnivore six years ago following four rules the internet swore by. I've since dropped all four, and improved each time, which says something about the internet.

Rule one: you need salt and electrolytes. I salted everything and carried sachets like a man expecting to be shipwrecked. Then I stopped and braced for the cramps. They never came. Better sleep did, and better lifting. It turns out the body can manage its own water if you let it be thirsty first.

Rule two: you need liver to complete the diet. I ate it weekly for three years. A single helping carries more vitamin A and copper than the upper limit for a day, and it tastes bitter, which is nature's way of writing "steady on" across a food. My mouth objected the entire time. Eventually I listened, and I've felt better every year since.

Rule three: chicken is a health food. Chicken is a record of what the bird was fed, which is corn and soy, kept in the skin and the fat. Those are the only parts with any flavour. Remove them and you're eating a damp napkin with a protein claim.

Rule four: to get lean, cut the fat. I went the other way. Ribeye cap, 20% mince, butter on both, cream wherever it'll fit. When I want to tighten up, the menu stays exactly as it is and the clock moves. I eat later. Then I eat like a man who's been told it's free.

So that's no salt, no liver, no chicken and more butter.

Each of those rules had somebody selling it. A sachet, a capsule, a meal-prep tub, a cutting plan.

The diet that's left has nothing in it to sell, and it's the only version that ever worked.



Mike
 
I'm going to say something the food industry has kept quiet for fifty years, and if this account goes dark you'll know why. The answer to nearly every question about what to eat is four beef patties with butter on top.

What's a quick, healthy breakfast?
Four patties and butter.

What should I eat after the gym?
Four patties and butter.

What can I cook in ten minutes after work?
Four patties and butter.

What's a high-protein lunch that isn't a sad chicken salad?
Four patties and butter.

What can I afford this week?
Four patties and butter.

What will keep me full until dinner?
Four patties and butter. That was dinner.

What do I feed a teenager who is permanently starving?
Six. And more butter.

What about the bun?
The bun was there to hold it while you walked. Sit down.

What about vegetables?
Put the butter where the vegetables were going to go.

Isn't that a bit basic?
It's ground steak and cream fat. People pay £30 for that under a French name.

You can see why this has been suppressed. There's no cookbook in it, because it would be one page long. There's no app, no powder, no 12-week plan and no sequel. An entire industry of meal kits, protein bars and nutritionists with ring lights rests on you never finding out.

I've said it now. If anyone asks, you heard it from a man who was last seen near a frying pan.



Mike
 
California has two devout communities that shun tobacco and alcohol, and the one that eats the pot roast lives longer.

Seventh-day Adventists, Loma Linda:
- Tobacco: no
- Alcohol: no
- Meat: discouraged, many vegetarian
- Life expectancy: men 78.5, women 82.3
- Vegetarian members only: men 83.3, women 85.7

Devout Mormons, same state:
- Tobacco: no
- Alcohol: no
- Meat: yes, with gravy
- Life expectancy: men 84.1, women 86.1

The first group is an official Blue Zone, with the books, the cookery series and the documentary. The author who named it has since admitted that his editor told him to go and find one in America.

The second group has funeral potatoes and no film crew.

Even the strictest vegetarians in Loma Linda finish behind the Mormon who had the beef.

Both churches preach against the cigarette. Only one preaches against the roast, and it is the one that buries its men first.



Mike
 
A tumour ferments sugar, and a ketone cannot be fermented. Everything that follows is chemistry.

Sugar can be burned without oxygen. A ketone can't.

Sugar can be burned without working mitochondria. A ketone can't.

Sugar is taken up by a tumour many times faster than by the tissue around it. That is how the scan finds it.

Sugar raises insulin, and insulin is a growth signal. Ketones rise only when insulin falls.

Sugar gets turned into lactate, which the tumour dumps on its neighbours to clear itself a path. Ketones leave nothing to dump.

Sugar is there at every meal, every snack and in every drink on the ward trolley. Ketones appear when the sugar stops.

Your brain, your heart and your muscle switch between the two without complaint. They've done it every night of your life.

A cancer cell is the one customer in the body that struggles with the switch, and it's the one we keep the sugar flowing for.

Otto Warburg described the fermenting tumour in the 1920s and collected a Nobel in 1931.

A century later the oncology ward still has a biscuit tin.



Mike
 
Two diabetes doctors, one Indian and one British, stood side by side for a photograph in 2004, and the picture has been indicting the vegetarian plate ever since.

Dr Chittaranjan Yajnik, Pune:
- BMI: 22.3
- Diet: mostly vegetarian
- Body fat: 21.2%

Dr John Yudkin, London:
- BMI: 22.3
- Diet: European, meat included
- Body fat: 9.1%

The same number on the chart, to the decimal. The Indian doctor looks the slimmer man in the picture and carries more than twice the fat, because there is so much less muscle and bone underneath it.

It starts before birth. Yajnik weighed the babies of Pune against the babies of Southampton.

- Pune newborn: 2.7kg
- Southampton newborn: 3.5kg

The Indian baby was short on muscle, smaller in the organs, and had held on to its fat. Thin and fat at once, on day one, built out of a mother's plate of rice and dal.

India files this under genetic predisposition. It is an odd sort of gene that only turns up where the meat does not.



Mike
 
Medieval people did not drink ale because the water was unsafe. They drank ale because it was the only way to get more grain into a man who was already full of it.

The myth is a favourite: filthy water, so everyone was slightly drunk from breakfast. It is wrong on both counts. The wells were fine, monks drank water by the rule, and the ale of the labourer was so weak it would not intoxicate a child.

What ale actually was:

- Barley, malted, boiled and fermented: bread in a cup
- The harvest worker's allowance on a manor: a gallon a day, sometimes two
- A quarter of the labourer's calories, by the accounts, sometimes more
- Brewed by the wife, at home, because the grain came in as wages

Add it up. Bread for breakfast, pottage of oats and beans at midday, bread and ale at night. The medieval peasant ate grain three times a day and drank it in between, and the ale is where the historians hid the third helping.

The lord's household drank the same barley as wine and beer, but the accounts of his table are three quarters flesh. The peasant's are three quarters grain, and a gallon of it was liquid.

So the myth of the drunken peasant protects a truth nobody wanted printed: a man kept on grain has to be given grain in every form there is, or he cannot get through the day. The water was drinkable. The problem was the plate.



Mike
 
Vegan leather is plastic. Polyurethane on a polyester backing, made from crude oil, coated with a solvent so toxic the EU restricts it, and it peels inside two years.

Vegan wool is plastic. Acrylic, which sheds more fibres per wash than any fabric ever tested, around 700,000 in a single load.

Vegan fur is plastic. Modacrylic, spun from coal and oil, and a fox coat in a charity shop will outlast every coat made of it.

Vegan silk is plastic. Polyester, or wood pulp dissolved in carbon disulphide, a chemical that sent factory workers mad in the 1930s.

Vegan down is plastic. A duvet of oil, which stops insulating the day it goes flat and cannot be washed back to life.

Vegan suede is plastic. Vegan cashmere is plastic. The pineapple leather, the mushroom leather, the cactus leather: all of it sealed in plastic, because the plant on its own falls apart in the rain.

Every wash sends it down the drain. Every wear sheds it into the air. Every year 92 million tonnes of it goes into the ground, where it stays for two centuries.

A third of the plastic in the ocean is clothing fibre.

It is in the fish. It is in the rain. It has been found in human blood, in the placenta, in the lungs, in the testicles, and in the brain, about a spoonful per head, and rising.

That is the compassionate option.

Wool goes in the ground and is gone in a year. Leather lasts thirty years and then rots. Silk is a worm. Down is a goose. Fur is a coat that was already a coat.

Every one of them grows on an animal, on rain and grass, and returns to the field it came from.

The vegan wardrobe is an oil well, cut to look like a farm, and it will be in your grandchildren's blood after the sheep it replaced has been soil for a century.

Wear the animal. It is the only fabric that knows how to leave.



Mike
 
Being vegan is honestly so simple. People overcomplicate it. You just don't eat anything that came from an animal, and that is the only rule there is.

Week one I cut the obvious ones. Meat, fish, eggs, dairy, honey. Easy. I had a fig to celebrate.

Then somebody on a forum told me about the fig. Certain figs are pollinated by a wasp that crawls inside, cannot get back out, and is digested by the fruit. So figs are a grey area. Fine. No figs.

Then it was the wine. Cleared with fish bladder, apparently. They call it isinglass, like somewhere in Tolkien. So I check the wine now. And the beer, which is the same bladder.

Then sugar. In America they whiten cane sugar through charred cattle bones, so that's the American biscuits gone.

Then the slice of lemon in my water. Waxed. The wax is shellac, which is scraped off an insect.

Red sweets are crushed beetles. I knew that one, everybody knows that one.

Bread. There's a dough improver made out of feathers. Duck feathers. In a bap.

My orange juice has added vitamin D. It comes from the grease in sheep's wool. So does the one in my cereal. Same sheep, for all I know.

Then my brother asked what the carrots were grown in, and I said soil, obviously, and he said blood, fish and bone. It's a fertiliser. It comes in a cheerful box at the garden centre. So I said I'd buy organic, and he said the organic ones are grown in manure, and asked me where I thought manure came from.

I asked him what pollinates the avocados and he said I didn't want to know.

Anyway, like I say, very simple. You just don't eat anything that came from an animal. I'm currently on tap water and porridge oats, and nobody is to tell me anything about the oats.



Mike
 
The oyster is served alive, priced by the mouthful, and defended by people who have never chewed one.

- Drinks 190 litres of estuary a day. Keeps the solids.
- Sewage overflow upstream. Three in four carry the vomiting bug.
- Smelter upriver. Nothing in the sea hoards cadmium better.
- Warm water, Vibrio. Kills one in five it reaches.
- The purification tank removes bacteria. The rest stays for you.
- Summer oysters go milky, so the trade bred a sterile one.
- Three sets of chromosomes. French hatchery. Yours by August.
- Poverty food in Dickens. Now £3.50, lemon included.
- Swallowed whole, because chewing tells you where it has been.

An oyster is the estuary's water filter, and nobody is supposed to eat the filter.



Mike
 
Raw milk is legal in England, and the law written to make it awkward has accidentally built the best food supply chain in the country.

You cannot buy it in a shop. No supermarket, no corner shop, no deli. A farmer put a vending machine of it in Selfridges, and in 2012 the regulator had it out again.

The rule is that it can only be sold by the farmer, directly, to you. At the farm gate. From his van. At his stall on the market. From a machine in his yard that takes a pound coin and fills your bottle while a cow watches.

The carton in your fridge took a longer road.

Supermarket milk:

- Pooled from hundreds of farms
- Tankered to a plant
- Separated, then reassembled to a number
- Heated
- Forced through a nozzle to smash the fat
- Bottled, trucked, shelved
- Several days old when you pour it

Raw milk:

- One farm
- One herd
- Yesterday

The farms that sell it are inspected twice a year. The herd has to be tested clear of TB and brucellosis. The milk is sampled. There is a name on the bottle and a track up to the house. And the person answerable for every pint is standing in front of you in wellies, which concentrates a farmer's mind in ways a tanker never has.

So a law meant to keep it off the shelves has done the one thing the rest of the food system can't manage. It has put the customer and the ruminant in the same yard.

The late Queen drank it all her life, from her own herd at Windsor. When William and Harry were at Eton she is reported to have had it bottled and sent over to them. Nobody rang the Food Standards Agency. Nobody suggested the heirs to the throne be switched to something from a tanker.

The milk tastes of something. The cream sits at the top in a thick yellow collar. People who've been "lactose intolerant" for twenty years drink a glass and wait for a punishment that doesn't arrive.

Find the farm. Take a bottle. Meet the ruminant.



Mike
 
Your ancestors came home empty-handed more days than not. Three days of nothing, then a kill the size of a car, and everything in you was built around that rhythm.

Your stomach stretches to four times its size, to take on a share of a carcass in one sitting, because the meat would not keep and the next one was not promised.

Your gallbladder sits loaded for days, waiting to dump bile onto a sudden mountain of fat. No leaf-eater needs one.

Your gut hands fat and protein a hormone that says enough, and the eating stops on its own. Sugar never got that hormone, because there was never a glut of it to stop.

You have one store, and it stores fat. A day's worth of sugar, no store for protein, and a body that can lay down a lean month's fuel in a single feast.

Your liver makes every gram of glucose you need out of the meat, because there was never a bag of rice on the savannah and there is still no essential carbohydrate.

Your brain, when the kill is gone and the days run empty, switches to ketones made from your own fat, and runs clearer on them than it ever did on bread.

Your growth hormone surges through the fast and holds your muscle, because a hunter who wasted in a lean week never hunted again.

Your hunger comes as a wave, sends you out, and passes. It was never meant to nag you to a cupboard every ninety minutes.

You share every bit of that kit with the lion, who eats 30 kilos at a kill and sleeps for two days, and the wolf, who eats a fifth of his own weight and walks away from the rest. Then nothing, until the next one.

The stretch, the store, the switch, the sleep after. All of it predator's equipment, and all of it in you.

You were built to gorge on fat, go without, and gorge again, and the going without was never the problem. It was the design.

So eat like it. A pound of fatty meat, a slab of butter on it, once or twice a day, until you cannot face another bite, and then nothing until you are properly hungry again.

Not a handful of almonds at eleven and a bowl of leaves at one. A lion does not graze. It feasts, and you were issued the same stomach.



Mike
 
You cannot govern a man with a herd.

A herd walks. It cannot be fenced, counted, tithed or taxed, and the man behind it eats every day without asking anyone's permission. A field stays where it is, and so does the man in it.

Every empire worked that out, and every empire did the same thing first.

The Normans took the deer and the boar off the Saxon, made touching one a hanging matter, and left him pottage.

The English took the cattle off the Irish, outlawed the herdsmen who drove them, and left them a root from the Andes. When the root failed, the cattle were still sailing out of Cork.

The English took the cattle off the Highlander, put sheep on the glen, and left him oats, a potato and a passage to Nova Scotia.

The Americans shot the bison from the trains, on purpose, because a colonel had said that every buffalo dead was an Indian gone, and left the Plains flour, sugar and lard by the sack.

The Americans burned the Navajo's sheep and peach orchards in 1864, marched the people 300 miles, and fed them white flour and bacon fat. Frybread was invented out of that ration.

The Soviets took the herds off the Kazakhs in 1930. A million and a half died inside three years, a third of the nation, and the survivors were handed a grain quota.

The Soviets took the herds off the Mongols, the greatest horsemen who ever lived, and handed them a loaf and a collective.

The Canadians shot the Inuit's sled dogs through the 1950s and 1960s, by the thousand, and the hunters who could no longer reach the seal moved into the settlement and ate from the store.

The British took the range off the Maasai by treaty, cut the cattle count, and left maize meal.

Every time, the animal first. Every time, the sack after. Every time, a people that had been tall, fed and impossible to govern became short, sick and on a register.

Now it is the climate. Trees on the Welsh hill. A buyout for the Dutch dairy farmer. A tenth of the Irish dairy herd gone. Fourteen grams of red meat a day, says a committee, for the planet.

The herd goes first. The sack comes after. In ten thousand years it has never once gone in the other order.

The only new part is that this time you are being asked to hand the cow over yourself, and to feel good about it.



Mike
 
Tooth decay is a plant disease, and the worst teeth in the Stone Age belonged to the people eating the most plants.

There is a cave in eastern Morocco called the Grotte des Pigeons. Around 15,000 years ago, well before farming and many thousands of years before anyone refined a grain of sugar, a community of hunter-gatherers buried their dead in it.

When the skeletons were examined, 51% of the adult teeth had cavities. Of 52 adults, only 3 had a clean mouth. Abscesses, teeth rotted to stumps, the lot. That is a decay rate you would expect from a modern population raised on fizzy drinks, and these people had never seen a field.

What they had seen was acorns. The cave floor was thick with the remains of them, along with pine nuts, gathered in bulk and stored. A sticky, starchy plant harvest, eaten daily. The bacteria in a human mouth ferment starch and sugar into acid, and the acid eats the enamel. That is all a cavity has ever been.

Compare the neighbours. Hunter-gatherers living mostly off animals routinely show decay in a low single-digit share of their teeth, and often in none at all. No toothbrush, no fluoride, no hygienist, no floss. Mouth bacteria cannot ferment meat or fat, so there was nothing to make the acid from.

So the experiment has been run, and it was run without sweets, without soft drinks and without a single food manufacturer to blame. Change one thing, the amount of plant starch going through the mouth, and a Stone Age jaw turns into a dentist's pension.

Your dentist knows the mechanism perfectly well. It is on the wall of the waiting room, next to the advice to eat plenty of wholegrains.

Brushing twice a day is how you apologise to your teeth for breakfast.



Mike
 
A statin is sold in the surgery as a tablet that lowers one number, and it works by shutting down the factory that makes a great deal more than the number.

What the doctor tells you:

- Lowers your cholesterol
- Protects your heart
- Perfectly safe
- Side effects are rare
- You'll be on it for life

What the tablet does:

- Blocks the enzyme at the top of the cholesterol production line
- Same line makes CoQ10, the fuel for heart muscle
- Cholesterol is the raw material for testosterone and oestrogen
- Also for cortisol, vitamin D and bile
- The brain holds 25% of the body's cholesterol

What follows:

- Aching legs, filed under age
- Fog and forgetfulness, added to the label in 2012
- Blood sugar creeping up, added the same day
- A diabetes prescription to sit beside the statin
- Heart attacks avoided: 1 patient in 100

"You'll be on it for life" was the only line of the consultation that came with no small print.



Mike
 
Ireland was a cattle nation for 5,000 years before anyone handed it a potato, and the paperwork on the cow goes back further than the paperwork on the country.

3700 BC. On the coast of Mayo, under six feet of bog, lie the oldest field walls on earth. Miles of them, laid out in parallel by people who had just arrived by boat with cattle, to fence pasture. The first thing anyone built in Ireland was a wall to keep a cow in.

1500 BC. Butter goes into the bog. Firkins of it, wrapped in bark, buried in the cold acid peat to keep, and forgotten. Turf-cutters have been digging it up ever since. Some of it is 3,000 years old and still smells of what it was.

700s. The law is written down, and the unit of everything in it is the cow. A man's honour price is counted in cows. A fine is paid in cows. The word for road means the way of cows, and is defined as wide enough for two of them. The word for a boy means a cowherd. The national epic, when it is set down, is about the theft of a bull.

800s. The Irish eat what they call the white foods: milk sweet and sour, curds, whey, butter, cheese hard and soft, and beef and mutton off the same animals. Grain is a side dish and a beer. There is no such thing in Ireland as a meal without an animal in it.

1188. The first Englishman to write the country up complains that the Irish will not plough, live on milk and flesh, and hold that the greatest wealth is liberty. He also notes, puzzled, that they grow tall and straight without any of the care an English mother takes. He does not connect the two.

1366. The Statute of Kilkenny makes it an offence to walk the herd to summer pasture on English-held land. The first law against the Irish cow.

1590s. The potato lands from the Americas. For a century it is a garden plant, a supplement, eaten beside the milk. Nobody yet lives on it.

1601. The Elizabethan commanders write down the strategy for Ulster: the Irish live all summer on their herds, so the way to end the war is to kill the cattle. They kill the cattle, and the north starves into submission.

1652. Cromwell's settlement. The grass changes hands, county by county, and the new owners run it for the English market.

1667. The English Parliament declares the Irish cow a nuisance, bans her from the ports, and Ireland turns its herds into salt beef and butter in barrels, for the Navy and the sugar islands, shipped out through Cork.

1770s. An English traveller records what a labourer is paid: a cabin, a potato patch, and the grass of one cow. The cow is now a wage, held at the landlord's pleasure, and she is the last one the family has.

1841. Three million people are living on the potato and almost nothing else, a working man getting through 14 lb a day, with buttermilk when the cow has calved. The animal food of the island is on the boats.

1845 to 1851. The potato fails. A million die, a million and a half leave, and through every year of it the cattle, the butter and the pigs sail for Liverpool. The clause that offers relief in return for the family's acre clears the land, and the cleared land goes under bullocks.

1906. The Ranch War. Tenants drive the graziers' cattle off the land at night, because the cow that replaced them is still standing where their fathers' cabins were.

1934. The Free State, unable to sell its cattle to England, hands out beef to the unemployed on vouchers. For the first time in 300 years the beef stops at the door.

2026. There are 7 million cattle in Ireland and 5 million people. The country is the largest exporter of grass-fed beef and dairy in Europe, and the Irish drink more milk per head than almost anyone alive. The moment the landlord left, the island went back to the cow as if the potato had never happened.

2023. The Irish Department of Agriculture models a cull of 200,000 dairy cows to meet an emissions target. The cow is 37% of the nation's carbon, the paper says.

Five thousand years, and the animal has been fenced for, fought over, counted, buried, bled, outlawed, killed to end a war, shipped past the starving, and finally, when the people got her back, blamed for the weather.

Ireland was never a potato country. It was a cattle country that had its cattle taken and was handed a tuber to keep it alive on the rent. The potato is the interruption. The cow is the story, and the story is not over, because somebody in Dublin is drafting the next law against her now.



Mike
 
University debate. Motion: the ice age giants died of the climate, not of us. A climate activist against an evolutionary anthropologist.

Activist: "The mammoth. The giant sloth. The woolly rhino. All gone at the end of the last ice age, when the world warmed. The habitat went, the animals went with it. And we're warming faster now."

Anthropologist: "Then explain Africa."

Activist: "Africa?"

Anthropologist: "Same planet. Same warming. Africa kept its elephants, its rhinos, its hippos, its giraffes. Why?"

Activist: "Different ecosystems."

Anthropologist: "Different neighbours. African animals grew up alongside us for two million years and learned what we were. Everywhere else, the giants met us fully formed, walking in over the horizon with spears. A face they'd never seen."

Activist: "That's a story, not evidence."

Anthropologist: "Then take the dates. Australia loses its giants around 45,000 years ago, after people arrive. The Americas lose theirs around 13,000 years ago, after people spread across them. Thirty thousand years apart, on opposite sides of the earth, and one thing in common."

Activist: "The climate was changing in both."

Anthropologist: "The climate turned dozens of times in two million years. Warm, cold, warm, cold. The mammoth walked through every one of them. It died in the one with a man in it."

Activist: "You can't pin that on people."

Anthropologist: "New Zealand. Nine species of moa. The biggest stood twelve feet with its neck up. People land around 1300. Inside two hundred years there isn't one left, and the cooking pits are full of them. What was the climate doing in 1350?"

Activist: "..."

Anthropologist: "Roughly nothing."

Activist: "The mammoth went because the tundra vanished."

Anthropologist: "Mammoths were alive on Wrangel Island while the Great Pyramid was going up. Six thousand years after the mainland herds were gone. Still eating, on a rock in the Arctic, because nobody had reached it. Then people did."

Activist: "So your position is that humans are a catastrophe."

Anthropologist: "My position is that humans are a predator. A very good one. On every continent we walked onto, the biggest, fattest, slowest meat in the landscape was gone within a few thousand years of the first footprint. A species that lived on roots and berries does not leave that pattern behind it."

Activist: "It's an uncomfortable thing to say."

Anthropologist: "It's a butcher's bill. You're welcome not to read it. What you can't do is blame the weather for what's in the cooking pits."



Mike
 
In 513 BC the King of Persia invaded a country with the largest army the world had seen, marched for weeks, and never found anyone to conquer, because the people lived on their herds and simply left.

Darius crossed the Danube into Scythia, the grassland north of the Black Sea, with a force Herodotus puts at 700,000. The Scythians did not meet him. They loaded their women and children into wagons, drove the cattle ahead of them, filled in the wells, burned the grass, and rode a day's march in front of the Persians, who followed, and starved, and followed.

Darius sent a herald with a message that still reads as a confession. Why do you keep running? If you think yourselves stronger, stand and fight. If weaker, send earth and water and submit. The Scythian king sent back the answer that every empire has hated since. We are not running from you. We are doing what we always do in peacetime. We have no towns and no planted fields, so there is nothing of ours you can take or burn to make us fight. If you want a battle, go and find the graves of our fathers and try to dig them up. Until then, we will fight when it suits us.

Then he sent a bird, a mouse, a frog and five arrows, and Darius went home.

A people that eats off a herd carries its food with it. It cannot be besieged, because it has no walls. It cannot be starved, because the granary is on legs. It cannot be taxed, because the assessor cannot find it in the same place twice. The Persians owned everything from Egypt to India, every one of it a country of fields, and could not lay a hand on a nation of cattle.

Herodotus, who was a townsman, could not decide whether to despise them or envy them. He wrote both.

Every empire since has learned the lesson Darius learned, and drawn the opposite conclusion. You cannot conquer a people on the herd. So you take the herd. Then they stay where they are put, and grow what they are told, and the assessor knows where to find them.



Mike
 
Je moet ingelogd zijn om te kunnen reageren. Log in | Registreer

Forum statistieken

Onderwerpen
4.737
Berichten
644.936
Leden
8.712
Nieuwste lid
Suzanne1972
Word vaste donateur van dit forum

Vrienden

Terug
Bovenaan